The coming days will certainly be days for looking inward. There will undoubtably be considerably discussion in the coming days and weeks about what went wrong, and what can be done to put Republicans back in the majority in this country.
One thought that has crossed my mind several times before, and is especially permeating today, is the question of why Republicans have lost the cities. Look beyond New York, Chicago, and San Francisco. Republicans have lost Cincinatti, Louisville, Salt Lake City, and Grand Rapids. McCain won a strong victory in Texas, but lost Dallas, Houston, Austin and San Antonio.
There is no north/south split, no east/west split. There is an urban/rural split. Yesterday, Republicans won in rural areas across the country, from upstate New York to downstate Illinois. But we were creamed in the cities, from the reddest to the bluest states.
It doesn't have to be this way. Republicans can make inroads into the cities. Rudy Guiliani served two terms as mayor of New York. The same with Richard Riordan in Los Angeles. Yes, both of these men were moderate Republicans, and liberal on social issues.
However, both were fiscally conservative and tough on crime, platforms that won over in their overwhelmingly Democratic-leaning cities.
This question isn't easy, and I don't have the answer, but it is one we must face. We cannot write off just about every city over 100,000 and expect to win nationally. We have to figure out how we can sell conservatism and Republicanism in the cities.