More and more of the details about the proposed $825 billion stimulus from President Barack Obama and the Democrat Congressional majorities are surfacing and it appears more and more that the proposition’s goals are not to stimulate the economy, but rather to reshape it in to socialism on steroids. By the spending proposed in the bill, the United States is going to start looking more and more like Sweden and France and less like the United States that we knew just two or three years ago.
First, let’s start with the tax cuts proposed in the bill. Business is struggling to borrow money from banks, like other private citizens are, and the value of their stock is in decline. All of this is thanks to economic conditions that have made business go from expanding and hiring more employees to consolidations and layoffs. Just today, 75,000 job cuts were expected from Caterpillar, Sprint, and Home Depot just to name a few.
For all of these pains where the highest taxes on sole proprietors, partnerships, and Chapter S corporations are going to remain at 35 percent. As for Chapter C corporations, they will still pay a 31 percent rate and their dividends will still be taxed again at the same income tax rate as paid by the shareholder. In other words, someone who has pre-tax earnings per share of $2.00 would end up seeing only anywhere from less than $0.90 to $1.17 (using the lowest tax rate of ten percent) per share that could be taken home after corporate and income taxes! That is an end tax rate for a shareholder ranging from 41.5 percent to over 55 percent! No wonder some people are hesitant to buy stock.
Instead, tax cuts are going to be given via Social Security payroll deductions at $1,000 for families and $500 for individuals. Let’s go back to last year when Americans received tax rebate checks for $600 (individuals) and $1,200 (families). Economists have concluded that less than 25 percent of the money from the tax rebate checks of 2008 was spent on goods and services (mostly Chinese made) while the remainder was used to pay down debt. We all know how well that worked out with the current recession.
Where tax cuts work is what Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton, and George W. Bush did. Reagan dropped the lower rate from 70 percent when he took office to 28 when he left and the economy grew dramatically. Bill Clinton cut the capital gains rate from 28 percent to 20 percent which led to the late-1990’s stock market boom. George W. Bush cut taxes on income, capital gains, and in other places and it led to an economic boom from 2003 to 2006. In every instance, tax revenues and America’s standard of living grew because of the increased economic activity by reducing the barriers of taxes.
What makes matters worse on the tax relief front is that the tax code changes won’t take hold until next year. If we are in such an urgent crisis, let’s do something from a tax standpoint that works and reduce rates going forward and make the tax cuts from the George W. Bush years permanent. However, as you read later, that will not be the motivation.
Next comes the infrastructure spending programs that sound good, but more will lead you to believe that this is not the right way to go forward. We have a nostalgic view about Franklin D. Roosevelt not because of the manner in which he ran the economy, but how he managed the war, mostly thanks to the great generalship of Dwight Eisenhower, Douglas MacArthur, George Patton, and others.
The New Deal that Roosevelt implemented twice government spending programs on infrastructure and blue-collar jobs. It’s “twice” because the first program failed and only government is insane enough to try a sequel (unless you voted Democrat for governor in Michigan and Illinois in 2006). As it turned out, economists at the University of California-Los Angeles (UCLA) determined that the New Deal actually delayed a full economic recovery by seven years.
The result was World War II and around-the-clock mass production for the war effort that ended the Great Depression in 1943. Think about that. The Great Depression, had the New Deal not been pursued, could have ended in 1936, on the eve of FDR’s reelection.
In total, there will be $90 billion in the $825 billion package spent on infrastructure alongside the $275 billion in tax cuts that won’t be realized until 2010. That’s a grand total of $365 billion, or just more than 44 percent of the package being spent to “stimulate” the economy.
The reality is that infrastructure spending programs don’t do the job and the tax cuts are insufficient. In total, the government is putting together a program designed to give window dressing with this package to make us feel as if President Obama and the Congressional Democrats are actually doing something. The reality is that if that something doesn’t do what we have the expectations are (reviving a stagnant economy), they’re toast.
So what happens with the remaining money? The remaining money will go to other projects that won’t be realized until long after Obama is out of office. Education spending, health care spending, and cover state shortfalls on Medicaid are nice, but the purpose of the bill is lost. The purpose is to jump-start the economy and to jump-start it now.
In the end, the American people will be more than $800 billion deeper in debt with no chance of either reviving the economy, creating jobs, or ending the current recession. Instead, the plan is to have enough debt on the books to where Obama and the Democrats can actually terminate all, if not most, of the Bush tax cuts.
In a previous post, I had mentioned that the four stages of the Great Depression were a credit crunch, a stock market crash, price destabilization, and tax increases. As it will turn out, the economic plan of Obama’s will generate more inflation either by increasing debt or the need to print more money (both of which are inflationary) and repealing the Bush tax cuts to result in the largest tax increase in American history.
I am not alone on a looming depression. There are a number of other economists, including Harry Dent, who accurately predicted the 1990’s economic boom. I guarantee that the Obama program will fail. I wish it weren’t true for the sake of this country because we need help. However, this isn’t the help we need but rather a shell game disguised as a push towards socialism that has been proven to fail in every instance it has been tried.
