One of the greatest Democratic tricks this past 8 years has been the Patriotism Dodge: their inexplicable ability to convince the press that their patriotism was being attacked at every turn. Sadly, the press rarely followed up the Democratic harumphing with a simple corrective: "However, nothing had been said about their patriotism." Their feigned outrage after the Max Cleland ad was probably the first notable example of this misdirection tactic, but they used it routinely.
Even more impressive, if that is the word, has been the Democratic ability to play the martyred patriot even as they were explicitly questioning the patriotism of their opponents. Unfortunately, they've provided two more charming examples...
"[Some Southern Senators] unpatriotically blocked a bill..." -- Rep. Dingell
""It is unacceptable for this un-American, frankly, behavior of these U.S. senators..." -- Gov. Jennifer Granholm
Republicans have ignored the patriotism dodge for far too long; long enough that it developed into conventional wisdom. They even took to preemptively explaining that they weren't questioning Democrat's patriotism. And yet, what do they do when Democrats explicitly do this? Nothing. Well, that's how you find yourself stuck in a bad narrative.
Republicans need to confront these charges head-on. Not in tersely worded statements to the press, letters to the editor or even blog posts (though, of course, we'd welcome a guest post response from any of the Senators charged). No, the Senators who have been maligned need to confront Rep. Dingell and Gov. Granholm personally. Stand outside Rep. Dingell's office (video running) and challenge him to repeat the charge in person and on camera. Do the same with Gov. Granholm.
Is confrontation unbecoming of a US Senator? It shouldn't be. It's certainly not as bad as failing to challenge these charges. But if Republicans are unwilling to defend themselves, they'd better get used to being defined for the next decade by their opponents. By people like this...
-
"John Ashcroft is not a patriot."—Howard Dean
-
"[In the Bush administration, there is] a group of people around the President whose main allegiance is to each other and their ideology rather than to the United States."—Howard Dean
-
"We hear them in the cries of the false patriots who bully dissenters into silence and submission".—Ted Kennedy
-
"I don't think it's patriotic to put on a flight suit and prance around on the deck of an aircraft carrier looking for a photo op." — Gen. Wesley Clark
-
"The policy that the administration is following in Iraq is ... anti-patriotic at the core..." — Sen. Bob Graham