| About Us | Contact | Donate | User Blogs | Login |
The Michelle Obama tape
Jim Geraghty has disovered something that casts (even more) doubt on the alleged "whitey" video and raises a serious question...
Sometimes, this rumor of this alleged tape of Michelle Obama denouncing “whitey” sounds like something out of a clichéd political thriller novel. Actually, it sounds exactly like something out of a clichéd political thriller novel. Specifically, Stephen Frey’s The Power Broker, published in 2006 by Ballantine Books. [...]
Either author Stephen Frey is clairvoyant, writing this book in 2006. Or this is one of the all time amazing coincidences. Or whoever started this rumor got the idea from a novel.
What if this alleged "whitey" video is part of a misinformation effort? Think about this:
- In 2004, questions about President Bush's National Guard service threatened to create media and image problems for the Bush campaign. However, when CBS and Dan Rather reported on National Guard documents that turned out to be forgeries, the fraud became the story, effectively ending the National Guard story and preemptively discrediting any other people who attempted to bring it up.
- The radical intellectual culture and Church from which Obama came could raise significant and ongoing problems for him in the 2008 campaign. What if somebody on the Left created this rumor - or even an actual, but fraudulent, video - in order to bring the story up, discredit it by revealing the fraud (but not the source), and preemptively delegitimize later attempts to raise such questions?
This is merely speculation, but it would certainly fit with the facts that we know and the way this story has been rolled out (to anonoymous sources, facilitated by movement progressives, but without any evidence of an original source).


Comments
With or without it...
If the tape exists and comes to light, it's not going to matter. His supporters lack the mental clarity to accept logic and reason. The are, quite frankly, so enamored by the mantra of "change and hope" that the vast majority of them didn't even exhibit the mental capacity to realize that they were holding their signs upside down during his latest speech.
Larry Johnson is the main purveyer of this
What do we know about Mr. Johnson?
a) He is ex-CIA
b) He is a Bush critic
c) In the summer of 2001, he wrote a NY Times op-ed on the irrational fear of terrorism
Seems disinformation and him might be good friends
where the Michelle Obama tape came from
Found a link Bob Beckel On Fox & Friends: 'Bombshell Heading Michelle Obama's Way' (Updated).. with this explanation:The Michelle Obama Rant Tape was filmed between June 26th - July 1st 2004 in Chicago, IL at the Rainbow/PUSH Coalition Conference at Trinity United Church: specifically the Women's Event.
Michelle Obama appeared as a panelist alongside Mrs. Khadijah Farrakhan and Mrs. James Meeks.
Bill Clinton spoke during the Conference, as did Bill Cosby and other speakers, but not at the panel Michelle attended.
Michelle Obama spoke at the Women's Event, but referenced Bill Clinton in her rant --- his presence at the conference was the impetus for her raving, it seems.
For about 30 minutes, Michelle Obama launched into a rant about the evils of America, and how America is to blame for the problems of Africa. Michelle personally blamed President Clinton for the deaths of millions of Africans and said America is responsible for the genocide of the Tutsis and other ethnic groups. She then launched into an attack on "whitey", and talked about solutions to black on black crime in the realm of diverting those actions onto white America. Her rant was fueled by the crowd: they reacted strongly to what she said, so she got more passionate and enraged, and that's when she completely loses it and says things that have made the mouths drop of everyone who's seen this.
The "tape" is a DVD that Trinity United sold on its website, and possibly offered free for download up until March 2008 when Trinity's site was scrubbed and the DVDs were no longer offered for sale.
This outburst happened just one month before the 2004 Democratic Convention, when Barack Obama delivered the keynote address.
This rumored video has been around for a while
Yet no one else has released it. That's beside the point. The GOP is being fooled into thinking that this will be sufficient to win the White House. CONSERVATIVES NEED TO TURN AWAY FROM THIS NOW!
disinformation
It never ceases to amaze me how often the disinformation theory works, whether intentionally or by accident. Other examples:
What did she not say,
and when did she not say it?
Seriously, it might be true that this whole story was made up to make us look like fools by spending so much time speculating about its origins -- or lack thereof.
While we're speculating, I never heard a single solitary soul say that Mitt Romney's faith was a problem for them. From whom did the media buy that line, originally?
"Trust but verify," said Mr. Reagan. Until someone verifies this, I'm not willing to trust it.
Eh
This doesn't sway me one way or the other. I mean, in the 1990s, Tom Clancy ended a book with a scenario eerily close to the 9-11 attacks on the Pentagon. Does that mean we should have discounted the early reports on 9-11 with the Pentagon? (I know there's important differences, but you catch my drift). Heck, just the fact that he wrote a book about an African American Senator with a nutty pastor is a heckuva coincidence.
I wouldn't put it past Larry
I wouldn't put it past Larry "Rove Will Be Indicted" Johnson & Co. to have made it up wholesale last minute to scare supers and Democratic voters into supporting Hillary.
I like Geraghty's note as to why he - a conservative blogger - is so interested in disproving this claim:
Speaking of movie plots...
This is exactly what the Cylons did for Baltar early in the new Battlestar Galactica series. They created some falsified photo's of him accessing the planetary defenses to turn them off, letting the planet be destroyed by the Cylons. He actually did do it.. but once the falsification was proven... future inquires were cut off in the same way. Then he was able to eventually go on to become vice president and then president...
Not really a relevant comment either way on the subject at hand.. but thought it was amusing.