| About Us | Contact | Donate | User Blogs | Login |
The Earned Media Failure of the GOP
I'm sitting here live just off the House floor where GOP members are continuing their protests against the Democrat majority for refusing an up or down vote on producing more American energy, especially offshore. This seems more relevant, now that McCain and Obama have finished their tiff over inflating tires. Today, around a dozen members here today, including the Minority Whip, Roy Blunt. They sent around an open letter last week that called upon Pelosi and her followers to return:
"We think it is unconscionable that Congress has gone on vacation before we have addressed the high gas prices that are crippling our economy and hurting millions of families. We are asking that you reconvene the House from your five-week vacation and schedule a vote on legislation to increase American energy production. Let us be clear, we are not asking for a guaranteed outcome, just the chance to vote."
Great language, but it's not getting any local media coverage. Of course, CNN and MSNBC would rather cover live events from small towns for Obama. And Fox News is just going to be Fox News.
If we're ever going to start successfully building a GOP farm team, we have to start feeding stuff to local papers, radio talk shows, and TV stations. The fact is that the party leadership focuses too much about getting the right amount of coverage in the New York Times or on CNN's Situation Room. But the fact is that local media outlets are always clamoring for stories and are willing to eat anything they're fed. Plus, we can be more creative with local media, where we have to be careful with what we put out to national outlets.
Example ... In the 2004 Senate race in Alaska between Tony Knowles (D) and Lisa Murkowski (R), one of the best moves of the campaign came when Tony Knowles started claiming in the spring of that year that he could convince other Dems in the Senate to drill in ANWR. Murkowski replied back by publishing an open letter to Tony Knowles, inviting him to take up a desk in her Senate office and start working Democrat senators that summer before the election. It made Knowles look like a fool. Sure it didn't get press coverage in the Washington Post or MSNBC. But it was front-page, leading story stuff for the Anchroage Daily News and KTUU-NBC.
Our earned media failure isn't a failure on the national level; it's a failure on the local and state level. Too many members of Congress that are on our side have an adversarial relationship with local media. Let's make our gains in new media while also making sure that any national conservative movement, that identifies local issues and leaders, has relationships with local old media outlets as well.
Michael McCaul of the Texas 10th district is speaking now ... I'm about to step onto the floor to watch.
- Matt Moon's blog
- Login or register to post comments


Comments
Good Point
When Fox shower the 'exclusive footage' of the House protest the video was worse quality than most American's vacation videos. Seem either local media, or just someone with a half-way decent camera could have gained some media attention with very little effort.
Maybe look a little harder
Nice to meet you this morning Matt, but you've missed the mark considerably. Here's a sample of the dozens of local media hits that House Republicans are getting across the country. Happy to send more if you and your readers are interested.
Op-Ed: Congress finally gets drilled on oil prices
Former SC Gov. James Edwards: Failure to expand oil production caused by Democrats
Gohmert urges fellow lawmakers to return to Capitol to 'drill now'
Muncie Star Press
Pence battles for more oil drilling
Spencer Daily Reporter
King among lawmakers refusing to accept vacation
Carlisle Sentinel
Platts brings grant, promotes federal energy bill
Hartford Courant
Shays Joins GOP's Odd Protest On Dimly Lit House Floor
Talk Radio News Service
Gingrich shows support for Republicans’ energy protest
Idaho Statesman
Rep. Sali backs GOP protest over inaction on energy
Philadelphia Bulletin
Dems Shut Lights Off On Energy Debate
Great Falls (MT) Tribune
Rehberg joins GOP energy policy protest
CNS News
‘Drill’ Meets ‘Don’t Drill’ on Capitol Hill
Helena (MT) Independent Record
Rehberg joins GOP energy protesters on House floor
Wichita Falls (TX) Times Record News
Editorial: And while Nero fiddled …
Salt Lake Tribune
Rep. Bishop joins GOP colleagues for vacation rail against Dems
KTAR News
House Republicans protest in D.C.
Medill Reports
On day 6, House Republicans still pushing Pelosi to bring Congress back for energy vote
Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Gingrich joins House revolt over oil drilling
This is an earned media success story
Here's my post on RedState explaining why. I provide a list much like Nick's, although broken down by congressional district.
I understand the point you're making in your follow-up post, but I think you underestimate the creativity of the congressmen you write about. I have interviewed more than two dozen over the past week, and the one question I've asked each of them was how the issue was playing back home. Almost all of them offered a different story about the impact of high energy prices -- and the different ways they were going about talking about it on the House floor.
You can read some of the examples on Twitter, where I've posted snippets from most of the interviews.
Thanks for your post, Rob ...
... I think we can obviously go back and forth on success vs. failure, or really what looks like a debate over our different definitions of success. One important measure of success is how we make our Democrat opponents respond in the local media, and how well we can play the earned media chess game with them. That's why I mentioned the Murkowski vs. Knowles story in this post because Lisa Murkowski used a creative method to respond to an important energy issue that made Tony Knowles have to respond to a lose-lose situation for him.
So in honor of the creativity I saw at today's press conference, here are a few more ideas:
I'm glad that you're hearing more stories, but often times stories like these on other issues die. Hopefully, the momentum will continue.
Great points, Matt
I hope people take these ideas seriously because they are great suggestions.
I also wanted to commend you personally for taking the time today to observe the Republican revolt firsthand. It was great to see another conservative blogger on the House floor. There have been too few us at the Capitol this week reporting on what is taking place.
Hey Matt, maybe you should
Hey Matt, maybe you should take Lisa Murkowski's advice: set up a desk in the NRCC chambers and start earning publicity for the guerillas.
The fact that this is not being covered by "n + 1" media outlets instead of "n" media outlets doesn't mean someone has failed to think creatively on the subject matter.
While Blunt's on the floor...
...maybe you can ask him where he was for the vote that could have cut this vacation short. On July 30th, he chose to have lunch with a fat cat rather than show up for a vote which would have stopped adjournment. It's doubly odd that he's now complaining about a vacation that he tacitly approved.
Blunt takes the cake in political sophistry...
... and he is still at it. This is how he describes the events of July 30th to his own southwest Missouri constituents on his own website:
“For the last two months, Republicans have used every single tool available to us to allow this House to vote on expanding access to America’s abundant, diverse and currently locked-away energy resources. During that same time, Democratic leaders have used every single tool available to them to deny this House that opportunity. They’ve even gone as far as preventing rank-and-file Democrats from working with Republicans to bring forth commonsense, bi-partisan energy solutions for the American people.
"Today, their goal was to adjourn the House as quickly as they could – even as Republicans stood by on the House floor prepared to debate the merits of producing new domestic energy for the American people. Instead, Democrats gaveled the day closed, switched off the cameras, turned off the lights, cut the mics, and ran for the exits. But Republicans remain on the floor right now: ready, willing and able to lead on the most important issue facing the American people. "
If this guy doesn't fess up soon, I, and hopefully other bloggers, will start inundating the good Representative's own southwest Missouri cyber home-world with his political incompetency and self-serving sophistry, if for no other reason than to get the truth out to his constituents.
Granted, we may not inform many, but we will definitely inform more than Rep. Blunt's own web propaganda sheet is designed to inform. And the first message I will put out is how Rep. Blunt has attempted to keep his own supporters in the dark as to his failure to be present on the House floor when the crucial vote for adjournment was taken, as evidenced above.
ex animo
davidfarrar