Media Blogs in Memeorandum Lean Left

UPDATE: View the raw data here.

I am a proud geek, and also an avid Memeorandum user, and so I jumped at the chance to install this Greasemonkey script visualizing political bias in Memeorandum. The script will highlight various blogs linking to an item in shades of red or blue depending on their linking behavior in the last three months. The script doesn't measure political bias per se, but if you've recently linked to a lot of liberal blogs, you are colored blue.

Look at the colors assigned to MSM sources and media-sponsored campaign blogs. Every single one that I could see -- except for Yahoo News in a separate link -- is colored blue:

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3229/2942128396_41fc4dd2cc.jpg

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3174/2942128370_38f67d2026.jpg?v=0

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3213/2942128344_8f3d806d4e.jpg?v=0

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3243/2941272715_8be992e92e.jpg?v=0

The New York Times and the AP are colored in the darkest shade of blue, along with Talking Points Memo:

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3067/2942160530_d2aac898e3.jpg?v=0

Even MSM bloggers I really like Jonathan Martin and Marc Ambinder (not included here, but the blue coloring was spotted in the wild) are colored blue. And though Martin is not a partisan, he did briefly work for National Review and covered the Republican primaries, so he should link to conservative blogs more than most.

I am personally not on the media bias bandwagon as much as some people. We've both won and lost elections with the media against us. But I tend to trust computational rather than polemical measurements thereof. Though this measurement doesn't nail political bias perfectly (FiveThirtyEight is colored light red) Google has rubbed more than a few pennies together on the idea that you are what you link to. (And the algorithm was built by Joshua Schachter, founder of Delicious, and, I'm certain, no right-wing hack.)

0
Your rating: None

Comments

MSM Skew

Believe it or not, Barack Obama's main economic advisor, Austan Goolsbee, discussed research into objectively determining political bias in the "non-opinion" portions of newspapers in a New York Times article back in 2006:

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/07/business/media/07scene.html

Interesting that the Greasemonkey script would seem to use a similar approach, substituting word choices with direct linking choices.

Blue is the colour of the Right. Except in the US.

Blue should be the colour for the Republicans. Red all across the globe is associated with leftist parties. Except in the post-2000 and Bush's america. It's symbolic of the problems and the incompetence of the Republican Party. Blue is a cool, calm colour and the Right in the US should reclaim it. This blog should too. It shouldn't share the same colour with ACORN. Ross Douthat is right on this.

So...the Left is winning?

Cool.

I take this to mean that leftist blogs are a more convincing source for valid/interesting news than are rightist blogs.

The Next Right is as close as I come to enjoying a right-leaning blog. The rest are merely hysterical. And yes, I recognize that many left-leaning blogs are hysterical as well.

But, face it, we're better at this game than you are. The "data" above proves it, no? 

No, Timothy

It means the media is clearly biased to the left.  If the media actually reported the news, they would be neutral - neither red nor blue.  Conservatives have been saying this for years, and liberals have been denying it for years.  Now that we have empirical proof, it will be a great deal harder for the media to hide their true leanings, and people can judge for themselves whether or not to believe what they say and write.

And isn't it interested that the Associated Press == New York Times == Time == MSNBC == Talking Points Memo (regarding their bias).  Of course, anyone not totally in the liberal tank already knew this.....

I don't fully understand this post but what is says to me

is that reporters find more information worth linking to on the liberal /progressive side of political divide. I find this as well (though there are a few good conservative sites- the next right being  my favorite.)  A bias towards truth and good reasoning is not going to result in equal number of linkings.  I have long suspected that higher information citizens tilt left. I'd love to see more research on this.  I seem to remember research that found FOX viewers as especially lacking in knowledge of issues and current events. I don't think many fox viewers/ limbaugh listeners are reading the blogs or the wealth of online news sources.