| About Us | Contact | Donate | User Blogs | Login |
Key 2008 House races
There will be plenty of attention to the Presidential race this year, and for good reason. Keeping the White House has got to be the highest priority for Republicans of all stripes.
One of the goals of The Next Right is to provide a central location at which junkies, activists, interest group people, etc. can find good information. If people are operating off of the same information, hopefully we as a movement can start to get on the same page.
We would like to invite contributors who know about these races to write about these races and others that might be important. Stuart Rothenberg's list of races and his categorization are below.
| Tilt R |
Toss Up |
Tilt D |
| AK AL (Young, R) | AL 5 (Open; Cramer, D) | GA 8 (Marshall, D) |
| IL 10 (Kirk, R) | AZ 1 (Open; Renzi, R) | NH 1 (Shea-Porter, D) |
| LA 4 (Open; McCrery, R) | CA 11 (McNerney, D) | NJ 3 (Open; Saxton, R) |
| NY 13 (Open; Fosella, R) | FL 16 (Mahoney, D) | |
| NY 29 (Kuhl, R) | KS 2 (Boyda, D) | |
| NC 8 (Hayes, R) | LA 6 (Cazayoux, D) | |
| TX 22 (Lampson, D) | MN 3 (Open; Ramstad, R) | |
| WA 8 (Reichert, R) | MS 1 (Childers, D) | |
| NJ 7 (Open; Ferguson, R) | ||
| NY 26 (Open; Reynolds, R) | ||
| NM 1 (Open; Wilson, R) | ||
| OH 15 (Open; Pryce, R) | ||
| OH 16 (Open; Regula, R) | ||
| PA 10 (Carney, D) |
My sense is that these are basically correct. A number of these depend on primaries. (note that Redstate's Erick Erickson has posted a calendar and feed of primaries) For example, if former Rep. Jeb Bradley (NH) wins his September 9th primary, I suspect that race moves into Toss Up. However, if Don Young (AK) wins his primary, I suspect it moves into Tilt D. (local polling suggests that)
I also suspect that Darren White (NM-1) is, perhaps, our best recruit of the cycle, and will probably be able to pull this off.
I want to know more. What is out there?
- Soren Dayton's blog
- Login or register to post comments


Comments
CT 4
Shays has had two near-death experiences but the Dem candidate from '04 and '06 has given up. What is the DC read on this race facing a new opponent?
I presume the DC types have us losing NY 20 and NY 25
Surprised at Rothenberg
I'm surprised that Rothenberg doesn't have Congressman Shays on either a toss-up or tilt list. The good thing about the Shays folks is that every cycle is a "knife fight in a phone booth" as they say, and they go to the fights prepared. With that said, Barack Obama & Ned Lamont are widely popular in CT-4 and Obama at the top of a short CT ballot (No U.S. Senate races this year) will make for interesting dynamics.
A sidenote here that may be of note: In CT, as many places, we have switched to optical scan ballots (sorry Oklahomans, "progressive" Connecticut is catching up to you only 17 years later) from lever machines - which changes, in a tactile way, how people vote. It will be interesting to see how this change in methodology changes vote totals down ballot.
a couple updates
IL 10 - Mark Kirk is my home district congressman. Its an area that is going Democratic very fast, and Obama will probably win the district by a much wider margin then Kerry or Gore (who both got between 50-53%). That being said, he's very popular even among Democrats for his support of Israel and perception as a moderate.
PA 10 - the stronger candidate, Chris Hackett, won a hotly contested Republican primary with backing from the Club for Growth. He is well positioned against Chris Carney in a district that Bush carried with 60% of the vote in 2004 and where Clinton beat Obama more than two to one in April. So he will benefit from a likely McCain landslide.
Hackett
Hackett will def give Carney a run for his money and Carney is one of the "blue dogs" who has dropped the ball on FISA. In the end i think Hackett wins but the Dem's are not going to let that seat go without a SERIOUS fight
.
Carney had Casey Jr. ahead of him in "06
and Obama is looking to get crushed in NE PA based on his woeful primary performance
Carney
I have a good pice on why Hackett is going to win
http://houseguru.blogspot.com/
This is my district as well. . .
I think the district trending democrat has more to do with the mayor of chicago being a towering figure and rthe face of the Democrats in the state. I can tell you that people of all stripes love Daley in teh suberbs. They aknowledge he is corrupt but feel chicago would be detroit without him. That being said Kirk won narrowly in 2006 in a really tough year and certain issues were not really in play.
His opponent Dan Seals faced a primary challenge from a former Clintonista who claimed seals was not a strong enough supporter of Israel. The mere preception of this coupled with Obama's nomination will scare away eldery jews (who arent so self hating). My grandma has told me that she and many of her friends will be voting republican for the first tiem in their lives this novemeber. you must keep in mind that many baby boomer jews are liberals before they are jewish. A liberal is always a liberal first. You would be astoned how many baby boomer jews think the J Wright issue is not an issue at all. Many jews from my town (Deerfield) are the self hating kind and buy into the hope change blah blah blah.
But also do not forget the pocket book issue. people dont really bleive the Clinton's will take their money. But they don't trust Obama on this one. Don't forget how selfish baby boomers are (and liberal jews ar eno differnt) . They dont want their retuirment investments taken away . many liberal jews are saying this to eachother. Howard Veit (Oraculations) and Roger L simon have noticed this out in LA.
LA-06
Today, one of the leading Republicans expected to challenge Don Taxyou, I mean Cazayoux, Chas Roemer (son of former Louisiana Governor Buddy Roemer) passed on the race.
The two likely Republican candidates will be Laurinda Calogone (the NRCC favorite) and Woody Jenkins (the favorite of social conservatives). If this holds, the Democrats will likely retain the seat because both are weak candidates.
ID-01
Congressman Bill Sali (R-ID) has the media establishment against him plus is being outraised by his Democratic opponent. I remain optomistic because of the composition of the district and Sali's good first district performance.
NH-1
For what it's worth, the latest polling has Carol Shea-Porter down against both Republicans. It's very early, but it's also worth noting that absolutely no one appears to be campaigning up here at the moment on the Republican side.
MN - 3
Does anyone know what is going on in MN? Does the party have anyone good running for that seat?
Reason for concern
MN 3 is one of those upscale districts where the party's ...hmm ..."brand" is in the most disrepute. It is a good think the Franken Senate race is unraveling so we have some breathing room ...but since we lost a rural district (MN 1) to a relative unknown in "06 I'm not all that confident. Perhaps a local can explain what is going on the ground there
MN CD 3
I am a former Republican member of the Minnesota House of Representatives whose district, prior to 2002 redistricting, was part of the 3rd CD. I'll give some random thoughts to the upcoming 3rd Congressional contest.
The Democratic endorsed candidate is Jigar Ashwin Madia, an unknown who filed for the seat in October of last year. He is of Indian (Asian) descent, a lawyer, and former Marine Captain who served as a legal counsel to the Iraqi government. He obtained the endorsement by outworking, outsmarting and overwhelming a sitting female state senator who was considered a shoe-in. He is reportedly well-spoken and likeable.
The DCCC is actively supporting him. He has raised a significant amount of money but lags behind his Republican opponent in this regard. He will need to work on issue development as his pronouncements on the issues show a complete lack of depth.
He is a "greenie" and proclaims we only have 2-3 years to act or face disaster on the global warming front. He calls on Americans to be patriotic and make the sacrifices required to confront this "grave threat." He is pro-choice and always makes it a point to voice his support for the LGBT community and their fight for liberty. He is clueless on the health care front and is open to a single payer approach.
The law firm he works for, Robbins Kaplan and Ciresi, is a nationally known leader of the plaintiff’s bar.
Several excellent candidates had voiced interest in the seat, but Paulsen's well known capacity for hard work quickly manifested itself and he soon was the last man standing when the Republican endorsement was determined. He has raised a lot of money in a short peroid of time.
Paulsen is a conservative, both fiscal and social, and will be a lot more reliable than Jim Ramstad ever was. He believes in markets, especially in health care, and understands that individual liberty is a bedrock American value.
Erik Paulsen knows the issues and can articulate his platform. Experienced and polished describe him well. He is also one of the hardest working guys I have ever met. No one will outwork him. He understands elections and has gathered an excellent campaign staff of similarly experienced campaigners. He walks into this race with his eyes wide open.
Given this CD, I am surprised that it is being considered a toss up. If Paulsen can't win this race, then we are in a lot of trouble. I consider him a safe bet.
What about PA-4?
Rematch of Melissa Hart v. Jason Altmire
Also, what about Jerry McNerney v. Dean Andal in CA-11?
What are people's thoughts about rematches? i.e. Jim Ryun in KS-2, and Melissa Hart in PA-4. Is it good to run the same candidate again after they lost in a previous cycle? Are they stronger or weaker than a different challenger?
Not Hart
I wouldn't put much faith in Hart re-taking PA-4.
I'm not sure one can generalize about rematches.
I have a better feeling about PA-11, Barletta vs Kanjorski.
Jim Ryun weaker
I'm a Republican in Kansas and it's hard for me to not believe Jim Ryun is in a weaker position to win against Boyda. I'd say if he wins the primary, the seat will move to leans Democrat.
Oregon-5
The fifth congressional district is special. Mike Erickson is a businessman, who has never had political office before, but two years ago he lost to a ten year incumbant by less than 2%. This year there is no incumbant. The fifth district went for the republican in the last two governors races, as well as the last attorney general race. It is very workable.
Staying with Oregon, here is some information for you. Senator Gordon Smith is the only Republican Senator on the west coast. Oregon is only one seat away from having the only Republican House on the "left" coast. And the 5th district is the only district actually favored in a recent NY times poll to flip Republican in the entire country.
On top of that Oregon is picking up another district in 2010, and with the election of Rick Dancer, a very moderate Republican, but a very popular one as well, that district might just turn out to be in a Republican area. I forsee a future in which Oregon has a Republican House, a Republican Senator, and 3 Republican Congressmen, to offset the three Democratic ones.
And all of this on the Left Coast?
House race - Dean Scontras
Dean Scontras for Congress - 1st District Maine......PRIMARY IS ONLY 12 DAYS AWAY!
[url]www.teamdean08.com[/url]
May 14, 2008 - National Right To Life Endorses Scontras for Congress!
Acknowledging Clear Differences in the Two Candidates' Positions, Flagship Pro-Life Group Issues Rare Endorsement in Republican Primary Election
PORTLAND - The National Right to Life Political Action Committee announced today their endorsement of 1st District Republican Congressional Candidate Dean Scontras. Given the strong support for Life among Maine's Republican Primary electorate, the endorsement gives Scontras significant momentum during the final weeks of the campaign. National Right to Life has more than 25,000 members in Maine's 1st Congressional District.
"This endorsement reflects your commitment to renewing a culture of life, not only in Maine, but throughout the nation," National Right to Life Executive Director David O'Steen told Scontras. "We look forward to working with you in Congress to restore legal protection for innocent life. Your willingness to take up the fight for life along the campaign trail and in the U.S. Congress makes us proud to endorse you."
also.....
Concerned Women Political Action Committee Endorses Pro-Family Scontras for Congress
Conservative Women's Organization Cites Clear Differences Between Scontras and His Republican Primary Opponent
PORTLAND, Maine- 1st District Republican Congressional Candidate Dean Scontras earned a national endorsement today from the Concerned Women Political Action Committee. Scontras' endorsement comes as a result of a strong performance at last night's Values Voters Forum held in Portland at the University of New England.
CWPAC endorsed Scontras in the June 10th Republican Primary election over Charles Summers where Values Voters will make up a significant portion of the electorate. Executive Director Mike Mears said the choice was an "obvious one".
"This was an obvious endorsement," said Mears. "Scontras is the only candidate in this race who will stand up for the unborn in Congress. If you are a values voter - Scontras is the clear choice."
"I am humbled by this show of support," said Scontras. "I pledge to work with Concerned Women of America to help them to have a significant, positive impact in Maine, Washington, D.C., and the nation and to ensure a pro-family future for our children and grandchildren."
CWPAC is affiliated with Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee, which is also affiliated with Concerned Women for America, the nation's largest public policy women's organization with more than 500,000 grassroots members nationwide.
This endorsement comes a week after the Women for Scontras coalition, led by Representative Kathy Chase (R-Wells) announced the support of more than 100 Republican women for Dean's campaign
NY20th
Incumbent Gillibrand (D) running against former State Repub Chairman Sandy Tredwell (R).
Toss up
- Gillibrand led freshmen in fundraising, no major errors in first term, courting farmers and NRA types - local press loves her, FOBs lend support, guidance.
-Tredwell has deep ties, and the District is weighted R - but that didn't help John Sweeney
IL-10, Boehner, Idiot NRCC
NY 20, Kirsten Gillibrand is very very beatable. Her victory last time was due to terrible staffing by sweeney and the fact that she had the entire press and political operation of new york democrats, many of whom are leading their presidential campaigns now-wolfson, ect in addition to spitzer and a beaten down state gop there that is in the gutter.
IL-10, Mark Kirk is probably, politically speaking the shrewdest and strongest politician in the House Republican conference right now. While John Bonheaded Boehner, this Cole dude, Hastert, and other idiots continue to lose easy GOP seats, Kirk has raised 3 million and a 30 point lead over a challenger who has run hard at him for the last 3 years and raised nearly as much money.
Reread that again, in an area we should be getting crushed, there is a Republican kicking a democrat hard in the teeth.
Oh and that happens to be in a deep blue state that happens to have a democratic presidential nominee named Obama. He, like Shays, 2 years ago, has everything going against him and yet is still standing.
Meanwhile all the idiots we have running things in d.c. can't figure out a way to get back the 65 seats that voted for Bush last term, despite Obama's super liberal agenda.
NY20th
fandom is absolutely right that Gillibrand is beatable. Clintons targeted Sweeney for his help in FL. but this is rightly a R seat. Even the D swing in the southern part of the District (Dutchess/Columbia Cty in particular) shouldn't allow a repeat by Gillibrand - BUT - Tredwell doesn't seem to have ANY traction at the local level. Isn't hitting the "checken dinner" circuit, isn't getting any press, no idea if he's raising money. Same sort of arrogance that sunk Sweeney.
Sweeney's drinking and marital problems sunk him
The DCCC has a bead on all our bad actors and Sweeney was one of them. They made sure Gillibrand was well funded and probably stoked the Times Union to sift through Sweeney's dirty laundry.
Now we can cry about the unfairness of it all or realize the days of carrying "good ol boys" with personal baggage are over. Had Fossella not completely immolated himself this spring, be sure the national Dems would have lit the torch after Labor Day ala Foley, Weldon et al. And I am not at all sure we've fully cleaned out the stable.
We need to replace damaged incumbents on the fly and on our own initiaitve or seats like NY 20 will be lost until the Dem incumbent does something egregiously foolish.
IN-09
I think I would add IN-09 to this list as a Toss-Up. This is generally a Republican District held currently by Baron Hill (D). This will be the fourth straight time that Baron Hill (D) and Mike Sodrel (R) will face each other for this district. Hill won in 2002, Sodrel in 2004, and Hill again in 2006.
NY-20
Gillibrand is vulnerable, but Treadwell may not be the candidate to knock here out. Now, if the GOP could get John Faso to run, he'd whallop her by a wide margin. The biggest challenge the GOP faces in the district is voter apathy, which ultimately sunk Sweeney, when GOP voters stayed home (notably in Columbia, Rensselaer, washington, and Warren counties).
Now, if the GOP could only come up with a real candidate for the 21st district, they might have a chance there, demographics not withstanding. So far, none of the candidates have any real traction, except maybe Tonko. But he left his Assembly seat for a reason, and Amedore won it for a reason.
NY 21
would be a possibility if the Dems nominated an unknown lefty and it was a decent GOP year. Even though Tonko is not from Albany County, he fits the McNulty/Stratton mold pretty well (moderate pothole politician Democrat) and should do well in the general election --should he avoid getting shocked in the primary.
In recent years, the GOP performance in must-win places like Colonie and Guilderland was subpar and made it unlikely they could have mustered much of a fight this year in 21.
Looking long term, it's quite likely NY 20 disappears in '12 and gets parcelled out among the lower Hudson district(now 19) , the metro Albany seat (now 21) , the Binghamton seat (now 20) and the Adirondack district (now 24).
NY 21
My gut feeling is that in the case of Colonie, the Dem's victory will be short lived. From what I'm to understand, the town GOP is revamping, and the election loss is being used to bring up a younger generation. But with the fiasco of Heritage Park, the tax increases, and the kerfuffle on Wolf Road, the Dem's may be facing some hard times in the near future in the Town. Bethlehem is another matter, as that's the new "place to escape to" for ex-CityCrats. Guilderland I'm woefully short of info on, so I can't make much of a comment on that.
As for the 21st, there's a reason Tonko left the Assembly, and Amedore won the district. Tonko's big advantages are that he's a known quantity, he has the party connections, and has the "gravitas" to raise cash. Buhrmaster, the main GOP candidate, just is too unknown, and worse, is in the fuel oil business. The only GOP'er with a real shot would be Tedisco, but that would mean losing his position in the Assembly minority leadership, and opening up his Assembly seat to a possible take over by the Dems.